Comparing Transportation Management Software to 3PL

Comparing Transportation Management Software to 3PL

A Transportation Management System (TMS) is positioned between an Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) system and also a delivery distribution version. There are ways a shipper can implement a TMS:

  • Create a TMS in-house

  • Outsource the TMS function into a Third Party Logistics (3PL) provider

  • Utilize transportation management software

Large shippers that Operate a delivery fleet usually create a TMS merchandise in house, while small shippers that do not have a fleet normally outsource the TMS function to a 3PL provider, or employ a TMS product – a sort of logistics software which allows shippers to execute a freight audit in addition to other logistics purposes without staffing logistics specialists, or contracting with a third party.

TMS Software versus 3PL

Based on the wants And demands of both TMS applications, the shipper and 3PL have benefits that are unique. When comparing a TMS product to a 3PL, the Benefits of each-pertaining to price, control, and carrier options-can are summed up as follows:


3PL’s Expense Depends on the type of supplier a shipper uses – a client programmer, a service developer, a client adapter, or a 3PL provider. Support developers and Conventional 3PL providers provide a range of services and a range of services. They are not a selection for TMS management. That leaves client adapters and client developers, each of which performs delivery administration.

Compared to the price of The expense of utilizing a client developer or a client adapter, transportation management applications can appear exorbitant Transport planning software. Even though the management function is outsourced, it is managed by logistics specialists, who make an average salary of $75,000-$90,000 annually.


Outsourcing the TMS Serve to a 3PL provider relieves of controlling the function 13, the shipper. For shippers preferring to execute their freight audit and enjoy having control over the delivery process applications produces a medium, although this is exactly what some shippers want. This is because it eliminates the expense of maintaining an in-house logistics section, yet it allows the shipper to control the TMS function.

Carrier Options

TMS software supplies Shippers with the number of choices. The amount of transport options that a 3PL provider considers is uncertain. Some suppliers use electronic posting systems which match heaps with carriers that are accessible, but others have business relationships and utilize them. The range of carrier choices it, and also using logistics software rather than 3PL is known to decrease shipping costs by ten per cent from the year provides is 1 reason why.


Transportation Management software provides a way for shippers to execute a freight audit along with TMS functions when compared to maintaining a TMS product. Outsourcing the TMS function is less costly than the strategy, but it does not give control over the delivery process, the same flexibility concerning cost as TMS applications, and carrier choices.

Comments are closed.